The federal government's decision to exempt YouTube from the upcoming teen social media ban set for December has sparked controversy and debate. 

Emails obtained reveal inconsistency in the government's statements. While an official email to YouTube's rivals indicated that no final decisions had been made, the government later claimed the exemption decision was finalised months ago. 

Critics, including major platforms like Snapchat, Facebook, and TikTok, have accused the government of giving YouTube preferential treatment, dubbing it a "sweetheart deal." These platforms argue that YouTube, which features algorithmic recommendations and endless auto-play, poses similar risks to minors as other social media sites. 

Communications Minister Michelle Rowland, yet to seek formal advice from the eSafety Commissioner, maintains the exemption was settled last year. 

However, the revelation of varying government communications has amplified dissatisfaction among industry players, who perceive it as contradicting the government's intent to protect underage users. 

As the legislative process continues, the issue remains contentious, with stakeholders eagerly awaiting the finalisation of which platforms will be included under the ban.

- CyberBeat